|Year : 2022 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 90-94
Comparative evaluation on clinical efficacy of active oxygen toothpaste with herbal toothpaste in supragingival plaque reduction among gingivitis patients: A randomized controlled trial
Dharshana Murugesan, S Elanchezhiyan, G Rajkumar Daniel, K Vennila, E Gayathri Priyadharshini, AS Udhayaa
Department of Periodontology, Vivekanandha Dental College for Women, Tiruchengode, Tamil Nadu, India
|Date of Submission||23-Nov-2021|
|Date of Acceptance||16-Nov-2022|
|Date of Web Publication||27-Dec-2022|
Dr. Dharshana Murugesan
24-2, Kamarajar Street, Athani (PO), Erode, Tamil Nadu
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Context: Gingivitis is a soft-tissue inflammation of the gingiva. It is initiated in the oral cavity by the accumulation of plaque. Among the various plaque control methods, dentifrices play a major role to reduce the microbial load in gingivitis patients. Herbal dentifrice reduces plaque levels and gingival inflammation. In a revolutionary process on dentifrice, BlueM (BM) International has recently introduced the BM dentifrice. Its mechanism of action is to reduce inflammation by controlled delivery of reactive oxygen species to injury sites. Aims: The aim of this study was to compare the clinical efficacy of two commercially available toothpaste, BM, and Dabur Red (DR) in gingivitis patients. Settings and Design: To compare the anti-plaque and anti-gingivitis efficacy of two commercially available toothpaste by measuring gingival, plaque, and bleeding indices in gingivitis patients. Subjects and Methods: A total of 45 patients with chronic gingivitis were included in the study. After oral prophylaxis, they were divided into three groups: Group A, Group B, and Group C who received BM toothpaste, DR toothpaste, and placebo toothpaste, respectively. The clinical parameters were recorded at baseline, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd weeks. Statistical Analysis Used: Data on the gingival index (GI) and plaque index (PI) and bleeding index (BI) were statistically analyzed by the mean and standard deviation between the groups using analysis of variance with Statistical Package for the Social Sciences software (SPSS version 20.0) with a 95% confidence level (P < 0.05). Results: The three groups showed significant reduction (P < 0.05) in PI, GI, and BI from baseline. The BM has more significant mean PI and BI than DR. Conclusions: This study demonstrated that active oxygen toothpaste has comparable anti-plaque and anti-gingivitis efficacies with herbal toothpaste (DR).
Keywords: BlueM, Dabur Red, gingivitis, reactive oxygen species
|How to cite this article:|
Murugesan D, Elanchezhiyan S, Daniel G R, Vennila K, Priyadharshini E G, Udhayaa A S. Comparative evaluation on clinical efficacy of active oxygen toothpaste with herbal toothpaste in supragingival plaque reduction among gingivitis patients: A randomized controlled trial. J Interdiscip Dentistry 2022;12:90-4
|How to cite this URL:|
Murugesan D, Elanchezhiyan S, Daniel G R, Vennila K, Priyadharshini E G, Udhayaa A S. Comparative evaluation on clinical efficacy of active oxygen toothpaste with herbal toothpaste in supragingival plaque reduction among gingivitis patients: A randomized controlled trial. J Interdiscip Dentistry [serial online] 2022 [cited 2023 Mar 27];12:90-4. Available from: https://www.jidonline.com/text.asp?2022/12/3/90/365613
| Clinical Relevance to Interdisciplinary Dentistry|| |
Good toothpaste helps in plaque and caries free environment in the oral cavity. It helps in maintaining the healthy Endo-Perio and Perio-Prostho inter-relationship.
| Introduction|| |
Gingivitis is the most common type of soft-tissue inflammation in dental practice. Progression of untreated gingivitis will lead to periodontitis. The presence of plaque is the main etiology for both gingivitis and periodontitis. Worldwide various plaque control methods are used to reduce the microbial load of oral disease. Among them, dentifrices play a major role. Hence, various formulations have been tried in dentifrices to maintain better oral hygiene. Due to natural resources, herbal dentifrices reduce plaque levels and gingival inflammation. Dabur Red® the herbal toothpaste mainly contains ingredients such as Acacia Arabia has an astringent effect, Echinacea has immune stimulatory properties, cinnamon has an antimicrobial effect, Caryophyllus aromaticus is a natural antiseptic, Syzygium jambolanum has an astringent and anti-inflammatory effect, peppermint oil has analgesic, antiseptic, and anti-inflammatory properties, and the pudina has better flavoring agents.
In a revolutionary process on dentifrice, BlueM (BM) International (the Netherlands) has recently introduced the BlueM® dentifrice. The mechanism of BM toothpaste is to deliver active oxygen (H2O2) in a controlled manner directly to the treatment site. In contact with saliva sodium perborate in the toothpaste is converted into sodium borate and H2O2. In low concentrations of 0.003%–0.015%, hydrogen peroxide has a disinfectant action and occurs together with the antibacterial reactive oxygen species during the respiratory burst of neutrophils in normal wound fluid and for lipid peroxidation of bacterial cell walls and has a chemotactic effect on leukocytes. Through the glucose oxidase process, the honey in the toothpaste can gradually release oxygen when it comes into contact with the saliva in the mouth. Then, the oxygen molecules (O2) can penetrate much deeper into the biofilm to kill the anaerobic bacteria. An oxygen molecule (O2) can also penetrate much deeper into the perimucosal seal around the implant. Methyl salicylate has an antiseptic effect and there is some thought that methyl salicylate may have an anti-inflammatory effect as well. Lactoferrin potently stimulates the proliferation and differentiation of primary osteoblasts.
There are limited studies are available regarding the efficacy of active oxygen-containing toothpaste over herbal toothpaste. Hence, the present study was to compare the clinical efficacy of active oxygen toothpaste and herbal toothpaste in supragingival plaque reduction among chronic gingivitis patients.
| Subjects and Methods|| |
The study was designed as a single-blind, parallel, randomized controlled clinical trial where the participants could be blinded. It was calculated with 95% power and an alpha error of 0.05 with the required sample size was 11. Hence, 15 patients in each group were selected by a lottery method. In that way, 45 patients in the age group of 18–25 with chronic gingivitis and at least 28 natural teeth with the absence of caries were selected from students of Vivekanandha Dental College for Women, Tiruchengode, Tamil Nadu.
The inclusion criteria were the gingival index (GI) ≥1 and plaque index (PI) ≥1 with no probing depth and no attachment loss. Willing participants with overall good health were included in the study. A written consent form was obtained from the participants. They were instructed to follow the protocols and they should not participate in other studies in the same duration.
The exclusion criteria were the patients with periodontitis of probing depth >4 mm, participants with antibiotic therapy, any systemic conditions, smoking, presence of removable or fixed orthodontic appliances, and lack of compliance with the study were excluded from the study.
A total of 45 patients were divided into three groups: Group A, Group B, and Group C containing 15 patients of each. After oral prophylaxis, Group A patients received 20 g of BM toothpaste, Group B patients received 20 g of Dabur Red (DR) herbal toothpaste, and Group C patients received 20 g of placebo toothpaste (PL) which contains 20 g of calcium carbonate and glycerol.
All the participants were instructed to brush their teeth for 3 min two times from day 1 to the completion of the study (3 weeks) with given toothpaste using the modified Bass method. The clinical parameter includes GI (Loe H and Silness P in 1963), PI (Silness P and Loe H in 1971), and sulcus bleeding index (BI) (Muhlemann H R and Son S in 1971) were recorded on the baseline, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd week, respectively [Flow Chart 1].
Data on GI and PI and BI were statistically analyzed by the mean and standard deviation between the groups using analysis of variance with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences software (IBM® SPSS® statistics version 20.0) with a 95% confidence level (P < 0.05).
| Results|| |
All 45 study participants (45 females) completed the 3 weeks study period. At baseline, there were no significant differences among the groups in gingival, plaque, and bleeding indices. At baseline, the PI mean score for BM, DR, and PL were 2.74, 2.64, and 2.78, respectively [Table 1] and [Graph 1]. The baseline GI mean score was 2.79, 2.81, and 2.83 [Table 2] and [Graph 2]. The baseline BI mean score was 2.76, 2.78, and 2.8 for all the groups [Table 3] and [Graph 3]. After the 21st day of results, the mean score for PI was 2, 2.14, and 2.59 for BM, DR, and PL, respectively [Table 1]. The mean GI was 2.06, 2.13, and 2.70 [Table 2]. The mean for BI was 1.93, 2.32, and 2.62 [Table 3]. Results reported for PI has been indicated the presence of significant differences between the baseline and 3rd week of results with a P = 0.03 (P < 0.05) for BM, P = 0.04 (P < 0.05) for DR, and a P = 0.5 (P > 0.05) for PL. For GI, the significant P = 0.04 (P < 0.05) for BM, P = 0.05 (P ≤ 0.05) for DR, and a P = 0.5 (P > 0.05) for PL. For BI, the significant P = 0.002 (P < 0.05) for BM, P = 0.03 (P < 0.05) for DR, and P = 0.5 (P > 0.05) for PL. The intergroup comparison of Group A, Group B, and Group C at baselines were 0.154, 0.232, and 0.420 for GI, PI, and BI, respectively [Table 4]. The intergroup comparison of Group A, Group B, and Group C at 3rd week were 0.000, 0.001, and 0.002 for GI, PI, and BI, respectively [Table 5].
From the observed data, there were no significant differences among the groups at baseline and in 3rd week. There was a significant reduction of plaque, gingival, and bleeding indices in all three groups. In that, the clinical parameters show the most significant differences between BM toothpaste and DR toothpaste.
| Discussion|| |
Since dental plaque is the main factor for the development of gingivitis, untreated chronic gingivitis may lead to periodontal disease which ultimately destroys the supporting structures of the tooth. Hence, the best plaque control measures help in the maintenance of proper oral hygiene. This can be effectively achieved by better mechanical plaque control methods such as toothbrush and medicated toothpaste.
Many studies have been done to prove the efficacy of nonherbal toothpaste with herbal toothpaste. Chemically, the nonherbal toothpaste mainly contains triclosan and chlorhexidine to prevent microbial load. However, some of these substances show side effects such as tooth staining and altered taste sensation. BM toothpaste has come under a revolutionary type of nonherbal toothpaste. This unique formula includes active oxygen from, i.e., honey, with xylitol and lactoferrin as supplemental active ingredients. Meanwhile, the following reports of Ozaki et al. and Sushma et al. showed (19.9% and 18.3% plaque reduction) and (60.36% and 59.89% gingivitis reduction), respectively, for herbal toothpaste over nonherbal toothpaste.,
The main purpose of the present study was to evaluate and compare the efficacy of active oxygen-containing toothpaste and herbal toothpaste with PL in the reduction of plaque and gingivitis. In this study, all 45 participants (45 females) completed the 3-week study duration. To decrease the periodontal variability, participants were selected from college students.
The study demonstrated that at baseline, there was no significant difference among the groups. In 3rd week, there was a significant amount of plaque reduction (2 ± 0.20, 2.14 ± 0.2, and 2.59 ± 0.21 for Groups A, B, and C, respectively) and gingivitis reduction (2.06 ± 0.25, 2.13 ± 0.23, and 2.70 ± 0.15) among the groups. Moreover, the results demonstrated that both toothpastes in this study showed an effective reduction of plaque and gingival inflammation. Several studies have proven the anti-plaque and anti-gingival effects of herbal toothpaste when compared to those of conventional toothpaste.,, However, BM may be considered more effective than DR. Because BM toothpaste contains lactoferrin, which is a protein that possesses iron binding/transferring, antibacterial, antifungal, antiviral, anti-inflammatory, and anticarcinogenic properties. A recent randomized clinical trial has demonstrated that a toothpaste containing enzymes and proteins was effective at preventing gingivitis compared to tooth brushing with a commercially available fluoride toothpaste. Therefore, the selection of toothpaste with superior plaque removal properties may be fundamental for the maintenance of patient's oral health. Other studies have reported that the regrowth of dental plaque can be arrested by proper oral hygiene techniques.,
Limitations of this study include the short period of study duration with a small study population. Hawthorne effect may get noticed. Further studies have been required for the large population of long duration.
Within the limitations, the present study demonstrated the effect of oxygen-containing toothpaste and herbal toothpaste in the oral hygiene maintenance of gingivitis patients. It also showed that oxygen-containing toothpaste is more potent than herbal toothpaste.
| Conclusions|| |
Oral hygiene maintenance is as much as essential in our day-to-day life process. Many toothpastes are commercially available in the market to attract patient interaction. Hence, the prescription of the correct toothpaste is the dentist's responsibility. In that way, active oxygen toothpaste has comparable plaque reduction and gingival inflammation reduction in gingivitis patients over herbal toothpaste.
First and foremost, praises and thanks to the GOD, the Almighty, for his showers of blessings and benevolence which made me excel and be successful in all my academic pursuits. I would like to extend my sincere and heartfelt obligation towards all the personages who have helped me in this endeavor. Without their active guidance, help, cooperation, and encouragement, I would not have made headway in this dissertation.
I would like to express my deep and sincere gratitude to my respected Dean Dr. (Capt.) S. Gokulanathan B.Sc., M. D. S. and Principal Dr. N. Balan M. D. S., Vivekanandha Dental College for Women, for permitting me to pursue this dissertation.
I am ineffably indebted to my guide Dr. S. Elanchezhiyan M. D. S., Professor and Head, Department of Periodontology, Vivekanandha Dental College for Women for conscientious guidance and encouragement to accomplish this assignment.
I extend my gratitude to my Professor Dr. Rajkumar Daniel M. D. S., Dr. Vennila M. D. S., and Dr. Gayathri Priyadharshini M. D. S., Dr. D. Surya M. D. S., Dr. Saranya M. D. S., Department of Periodontology. Their prompt inspirations and timely suggestions with kindness, enthusiasm, and dynamism have enabled me to complete my dissertation.
I am extremely grateful to my Parents Mr. K. Murugesan. Mrs. M. Alagumani and my Grandparents for their love, prayers, care, and sacrifices for educating and preparing me for my future.
I am very much thankful to my husband Dr. S. Dhipak for his love, understanding, prayers, and continuous support to complete this dissertation work. Also, I express my thanks to my in-laws Mr. V. Sampath Kumar and Mrs. S. Chitra for their support and valuable prayers.
My heartful thanks to my postgraduate colleagues Dr. Jananippriya V, Dr. Niveditha P, Dr. Preethi M., Dr. Aarthi C., Dr. Nirosa T., Dr. Subhashini S V, Dr. Priyadharshini R, Dr. Anbarasi T, Dr. SwathiPriya. A, Dr. Rudhra K, Dr. Udhaya A S, and other friends. I thank all nonteaching staff for their mental and physical support rendered throughout my work.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Barnes VM, Richter R, DeVizio W. Comparison of the short-term antiplaque/antibacterial efficacy of two commercial dentifrices. J Clin Dent 2010;21:101-4.
Radafshar G, Mahboob F, Kazemnejad E. A study to assess the plaque inhibitory action of herbal based toothpaste: A double blind controlled clinical trial. J Med Plants Res 2010;4:1182-6.
Dalton SJ, Whiting CV, Bailey JR, Mitchell DC, Tarlton JF. Mechanisms of chronic skin ulceration linking lactate, transforming growth factor-beta, vascular endothelial growth factor, collagen remodeling, collagen stability, and defective angiogenesis. J Invest Dermatol 2007;127:958-68.
Tatikonda A, Debnath S, Chauhan VS, Chaurasia VR, Taranath M, Sharma AM. Effects of herbal and non-herbal toothpastes on plaque and gingivitis: A clinical comparative study. J Int Soc Prev Community Dent 2014;4:S126-9.
Cunha EJ, Auersvald CM, Deliberador TM, Gonzaga CC, Esteban Florez FL, Correr GM, et al.
Effects of active oxygen toothpaste in supragingival biofilm reduction: A randomized controlled clinical trial. Int J Dent 2019;2019:3938214.
Loe H. The gingival index, the plaque index and the retention index systems. Journal of Periodontology. 1967;38:610-6.
Ozaki F, Pannuti CM, Imbronito AV, Pessotti W, Saraiva L, de Freitas NM, et al.
Efficacy of a herbal toothpaste on patients with established gingivitis – A randomized controlled trial. Braz Oral Res 2006;20:172-7.
Sushma S, Nandlal B, Srilatha KT. A comparative evaluation of a commercially available herbal and non-herbal dentifrice on dental plaque and gingivitis in children. A residential school based oral health programme. J Dent Oral Hyg 2011;3:109-13.
George J, Hegde S, Rajesh KS, Kumar A. The efficacy of a herbal-based toothpaste in the control of plaque and gingivitis: A clinico-biochemical study. Indian J Dent Res 2009;20:480-2.
] [Full text]
Wang B, Timilsena YP, Blanch E, Adhikari B. Lactoferrin: Structure, function, denaturation and digestion. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 2019;59:580-96.
Daly S, Seong J, Newcombe R, Davies M, Nicholson J, Edwards M, et al.
A randomised clinical trial to determine the effect of a toothpaste containing enzymes and proteins on gum health over 3 months. J Dent 2019;80 Suppl 1:S26-32.
Rubido S, Fernández-Feijoo J, Limeres J, García-Caballero L, Abeleira MT, Diz P. In vivo
antiplaque effect of three edible toothpastes. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal 2014;19:e88-92.
Reddy R, Palaparthy R, Durvasula S, Koppolu P, Elkhatat E, Assiri KA, et al.
Gingivitis and plaque prevention using three commercially available dentifrices: A comparative clinical and microbiological randomized control parallel study. Int J Pharm Investig 2017;7:111-8.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5]